Barrett Burgin on Horror, Faith, and Worlds Without Number | Pioneers Ep. 5
Why would a believing Latter-day Saint make horror films? Barrett Burgin, the writer and director of Cryo and The Angel, says his reasons come straight from scripture.
He and Carl Youngblood talk about which parts of their own theology Latter-day Saints have grown shy of, why they write so much science fiction and bring so little of it to church, and why infinite regress and eternal recurrence seem to Barrett so compelling and so inevitable.
Pioneers is the podcast of the Mormon Transhumanist Association: long-form conversations with the people pushing on today’s frontiers in science, technology, history, and theology, and what drives them. Every episode, with video and a full transcript, lives at https://transfigurism.org/news-and-podcasts/podcasts/pioneers

Carl Youngblood co-founded the MTA in 2006 and has served as its President and CEO since 2021. He is engaged with the Association’s efforts to explore the intersection of Mormon theology and transhumanist philosophy. Among the many initiatives that Carl has been involved with, he has designed and built the Association’s current website, which unifies all prior content in a single location using inspiring visuals and animations. ¶ Youngblood’s professional career spans more than two decades of full-stack software development at the intersection of Silicon Slopes and Silicon Valley. He was an early employee at Omniture (acquired by Adobe), a founding engineering leader at Divvy (a Utah-based unicorn startup), co-founder of Blockscale LLC (a blockchain services firm eventually contracted into Coinbase), and Senior Solutions Architect for Amazon Managed Blockchain at AWS. His technical fluency ranges from scalable web architecture to blockchain infrastructure—the kind of deep engineering experience that grounds his theological speculation in working knowledge of the systems he writes about. ¶ Under his leadership, the Association has developed its mission of promoting abundant human flourishing through the compassionate use of science and technology, fostering dialogue across secular and religious audiences and arguing that each has something essential to learn from the other. His writing, collected on his blog From the Depths, spans over a decade of conference presentations and theological essays: meditations on participatory resurrection, the alignment of artificial intelligence read through the Grand Council narrative, intelligence as eternal and multifaceted, and religion as social technology. He writes, as a colleague has observed, with warmth and accessibility on questions of momentous practical consequence—how to navigate faith crisis without losing faith’s power, how to think about resurrection as something we actively participate in rather than passively receive. ¶ Youngblood’s distinctive contribution to transhumanism is the integration of serious technical expertise with serious theological reflection. He embodies the Mormon transhumanist conviction that scientific and spiritual development are not parallel tracks but a single path—that the learning required to build better systems is continuous with the exaltation Mormon theology envisions, and that human ingenuity, rightly oriented, is itself a divine imperative.
Keep going
Related talks
57:09Elle Griffin on the Mormon Welfare State | Pioneers Ep. 4
Carl Youngblood
56:24Samo Burja on Old Institutions and New Frontiers | Pioneers Ep. 3
Carl Youngblood, Steven Christiansen, Samo Burja

Introducing the MTA’s new podcast: Pioneers
Carl Youngblood
17:01Algorithmic Advent
Carl Youngblood
25:39Conference Intro and Web3 and the Promise of Decentralized Governance
Carl Youngblood
1:51:46MTA podcast
Carl Youngblood
Pioneers podcast
Long-form conversations with the people pushing on today's frontiers. All episodes
Next event: The Life of a Young Cosmist · 2026.12.13 20:00 MST
Transcript
Barrett Burgin
The fact that story and myth take the shape that they do, and the fact that they resonate so deeply and so universally, and there’s kind of almost laws of these things, like there are laws of physics. They just work. I think that there’s a relationship between that and revelation, between envisionment, and that is practicing godhood. Elder Neal A. Maxwell called us, ‘God’s an embryo.’ Like that kind of visualization that life is, even in a larger sense, embryonic. The idea that if it can be done, it will be done. And if it will be done, it has been done. And if it has been done, then we are living in a plan of salvation in an endless generation of gods. Faith is the terror of facing the pit. It’s not the safety of staying in the Garden of Eden. That’s not faith.
Carl Youngblood
Latter-day Saints have a test for angels. If a messenger appears, Joseph Smith taught, offer your hand, and what you feel tells you what you’re dealing with. Most of us picked it up in seminary and filed it away as an interesting curiosity. Barrett Burgin made a horror film about it, and one of the biggest horror channels on YouTube put it in front of an audience that had never heard of it. Barrett is a writer and director from Knoxville, Tennessee, by way of the BYU film program. His feature, Cryo, went out through Saban Films in 2022. And The Angel, the short he made with his wife, Jessica, played the Cannes short film corner before landing on that channel this spring. He runs Burgindie Pictures, a company that describes itself as kindled by the cosmic ambitions of our pioneer ancestors. He is an active Latter-day Saint who grew up in the Bible Belt, and he has made peace with being the strange one at the table.
Carl Youngblood
Pioneers is a show about trailblazers of every kind, and some of them work behind a camera. When Brigham Young dedicated the Salt Lake Theater in 1862, he said that on its stage could be shown, quote, ‘evil and its consequences, good and its happy results and rewards,’ unquote. He wanted the Saints to see both. Barrett has taken him at his word. His films put the dark half on screen, along with the light. And the way Latter-day Saints have reacted, some grateful and some uneasy, might be a fair measure of how well we have kept Brother Brigham’s counsel.
Carl Youngblood
We talked about why a believer makes horror, and why he thinks a scary story is an act of faith. About what the Kardashev scale, which ranks civilizations by how much of a planet, a star, or a galaxy they can harness, has to do with worlds without number. Also about why Latter-day Saints write so much science fiction, and bring so little of it to church. And about the debate now circulating on Mormon YouTube over whether God had a God. He has a view on that, and he was eager to share it with me. Here is my conversation with Barrett Burgin.
Carl Youngblood
Barrett Burgin, thank you so much for being on the Pioneers Podcast.
Barrett Burgin
Thank you for having me.
Carl Youngblood
It’s a pleasure to have you. You came all the way out from Tennessee for a trip to Utah.
Barrett Burgin
Yes.
Carl Youngblood
And took some time to stop into the studio, so thank you.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah, absolutely. Glad to be here.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah, so you’ve made a career so far in storytelling. Let’s talk more about that.
Barrett Burgin
Sure.
Carl Youngblood
Give us some of your origin story.
Barrett Burgin
Okay. I’m an artist, you know, composer, filmmaker. When I was a kid, I was kind of into all the arts, acting, writing, drawing. And, you know, at a very young age, that kind of culminated for me into movies, into broad storytelling and incorporating all the different arts. And so all throughout my childhood and even into high school and then, you know, going on my mission, like I knew that’s what I wanted to do, was tell stories through movies.
Barrett Burgin
I wouldn’t even consider myself like a strict cinephile, you know, it’s not the process of filmmaking, though I love the process and have become so acquainted with it. You know, some people, it’s the magic of the film and the cut and everything. That’s great. But for me, I think it has more to do with envisioning something and bringing it to life and telling a story and, you know, bringing someone into another world that allows them to kind of reimagine things. I think storytelling can be used to convey an idea that can be hard to put into words. And as a child, I just kind of loved the escapism of it all. I loved the imagination of it all, that it’s like, oh, this can transport me to other worlds. But, you know, kind of world building and escapism for its own sake is not enough. And it’s as I got older that I realized that so much of this already existed within religion, within theology and myth-making.
Barrett Burgin
And, you know, it was in starting to research as a young adult that I realized that, I’m not sure if you’re familiar with Jonathan Haidt and The Righteous Mind and his research. But it became very clear to me that, like, when it comes to mythology, for example, when it comes to Book of Mormon stories or Bible stories and the debates over their, you know, their reality. Like, is this actually functionally real? Did this really happen? I think that’s an interesting question. And I think it’s worth considering. But it’s not the most interesting question. Because what I learned by studying Haidt is that that’s how the story would have to be written, whether it happened or not. It would have to be written that way in order to stick, in order to be sticky, and in order for us to kind of glean the utility from it. And so that, to me, became a bigger testament of God. Like, it’s like, why? Why is that how it would have to be?
Barrett Burgin
That my brother-in-law, Jake, talks about, like, he kind of calls it ‘as if it were.’ Like, it’s more useful to treat theological concepts as though they were true, whether or not they literally happened. And by learning about science and physics and story and neuroscience and how those things intersect, like, to me, that becomes kind of, it opens doors rather than closes them. And there becomes a lot more room for, like, oh, maybe this all functions at a much higher level than our kind of very limited, kind of myopic agendas want it to be.
Barrett Burgin
And so all of a sudden, it’s like, you know, as a young man, I really kind of went down some of those materialist questions and the new atheism and all the different religions and found on the other side of it, like, a deep, deep belief and love for Mormonism and the doors and the possibilities that it provides. And so all of a sudden, like, the Book of Mormon and these old stories in the Old Testament and in the New Testament, like, and presumably the Book of Mormon, like, they’re essential. They’re super important. So I know that’s a kind of a long answer to why storytelling and my career and whatnot, but I don’t know how to not combine that with filmmaking and storytelling and identity and high concept and the peculiarity and the fascination that Mormonism is and the opportunities that it provides that I just don’t find in any other faith. I love religion, like, I’m no expert, but I could tell you quite a bit about dozens of religious traditions and I attend them and feel holy envy and enjoy them. And I love that Mormonism allows me to sort of claim it all and go like, ‘Yeah, like, there’s truth in all things,’ you know, and yet in them, I don’t quite find so much. It doesn’t mean that this is culturally how we always do it, but like the legitimate doctrine of this kind of expansive, you know, open canon, if you will.
Carl Youngblood
And in every way.
Barrett Burgin
And so that’s part of what drew me also to the Mormon Transhumanist Association is I just recognized a lot of familiarity in some of the ideas and the concepts and the discovery, if that makes sense.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. Wow. There’s so many different directions we could take it after you open that way. One of the things that came to my mind as you were talking is some anthropological concepts about religion. There’s a famous anthropologist named Clifford Geertz, whose definition of religion is quite well known. And he describes religion as a system of symbols that is used by some group of people to make sense of the world, to give it an aura of what he calls ‘factuality.’
Carl Youngblood
And so he sort of points out that there are many different aspects to the way cultures form and the ways they identify whether you’re in or out of that culture and whether you belong in a certain way. And that all of the different symbols and rituals and other behaviors that they engage in are, they all work towards making sense out of a certain worldview. And so what you were saying about the way things sort of had to be based on the way the stories got told just kind of reminds me of this definition. And in particular, there’s this word that we sometimes use, you know, myth is often used in the context of religion. And I think some people today have this anemic version of what that means, that it’s sort of like a fake story, a fable of some kind. But in an academic sense, it means far more than that. It’s sort of like an archetypal narrative that isn’t necessarily untrue. In fact, in some of the deepest ways, it’s deeply true.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah.
Carl Youngblood
But tell me more about that and about how narrative relates to story.
Barrett Burgin
First of all, like there’s a great book by John Yorke called Into the Woods, not the excellent musical, but story structure. He sort of gets at this idea that I find very interesting, which is that story has a shape. Okay. Like, like this is why great stories kind of boil down to certain fundamentals because they resonate within us. And I feel like that fact alone and symbols and myth-making and how it works, like it’s sort of a test of itself. You can make the claim that it’s an evolutionary advantage and that it just is sort of a quirk of, you know, evolutionary development. And that’s, I think it’s a totally fair claim to make.
Barrett Burgin
But, and maybe this is my meaning making at work here, but like kind of how historians will sometimes conclude something based on the vastness of the independent evidence, even if like in isolation, you can explain it away by having a sort of tapestry of like all of this sort of points to this shaped hole. It’s not the God of the gap. I’m not a fan of the God of the gap, like thinking, which is just, you know, the idea that like, because we can’t explain it, it must be God. It’s even how we kind of deal with miracles. Sometimes I brush up against where it’s like, I think the miraculous is demonstrating that there’s a dependence on God, but surely there is a science to it. Because if it’s not that things are not possible, it’s that with God, all things are possible. And so we’ll get to that in a minute. But like the fact that story and myth take the shape that they do and the fact that they resonate so deeply and so universally, and there’s kind of almost laws of these things. Like there’s like, there are laws of physics. They just, they just work.
Carl Youngblood
They’re also kind of contextual in the sense that like for each culture, they may use different elements to tell the same story, right?
Barrett Burgin
Exactly. That’s right. So it’s not to flatten it, but it’s, it’s this kind of consistency that shows up and that it, that it’s true that like in application, sort of like the Book of Mormon claims, like the only evidence as a book that I can provide you is that if you apply, it works, you know, and I almost a Pascal’s wager a little, a little bit, but, but, but a little bit more sophisticated than that. That sort of thing really like leads me to believe that there is a design behind it because, because it is designed, you know, and, and the designed nature of the thing is what, what suddenly kind of just resonates and sort of attests of itself. And again, I don’t, I don’t mean to dismiss that, like that can happen sort of chaotically, but even it happening chaotically, this is this.
Carl Youngblood
It’s like the people in the story sort of keep bringing it back to the direction that they’re trying to take it.
Barrett Burgin
That’s right. Exactly. And I want to take this idea just a little further and it’s a little bit, maybe it has been alarming to some people when I put it this way. Are you familiar with a type one, a type two and a type three civilization?
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. The Kardashev scale, right, that you’re referring to?
Barrett Burgin
Yeah, that’s right.
Carl Youngblood
And so we should probably like actually briefly explain that.
Barrett Burgin
So would you mind?
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. So as I understand it, the Kardashev scale for type one is a planetary scale and type two would be a stellar, like a star system level.
Barrett Burgin
Yes.
Carl Youngblood
And type three would be a galactic level. Exactly. And it’s about like to what extent the society in question is utilizing the energy available to it.
Barrett Burgin
That’s right.
Carl Youngblood
So at the planetary scale, they’re using the sun in various ways, maybe using the elements that are in the earth to like burn things and produce certain things that help them achieve their goals. But they’re confined to a certain scale, right? As we move more towards the star system level, we’re starting to discuss, not yet fully implement, you know, things that would actually utilize more of the power of the sun. And presumably in the far-flung future, we might even start visiting multiple star systems, right?
Barrett Burgin
Exactly. That’s perfectly put. And this is like a serious thought experiment. It’s the idea of harnessing energy, like, you know, to achieve goals. To achieve goals. When you think of, and I promise this relates back to story and to sort of like attesting to itself. Like, it is theoretically possible. We might not have the organization or the technology available to us, but this isn’t some far-flung like science fiction idea. In theory, if we understood how to harness the energy of the entire sun as like a fully renewable energy source for billions of years, like a type one civilization is an achievable thing.
Barrett Burgin
Even if it feels like in the far distant future, this is also something about AI that I feel like people never understand what exponential means. Like exponential is constantly compounding on itself. And so I’ll hear people talk about AI and be like, ‘Well, that’ll never happen. That’s so many years in the future.’ And I’m like, ‘I don’t think you understand.’
Carl Youngblood
They’re not thinking exponentially. Exponentially.
Barrett Burgin
And I don’t think you understand. Like, it’s totally possible. And I guess that would be level two, right?
Carl Youngblood
Like, level two is where you’re starting to harness the entire stellar system.
Barrett Burgin
The whole stellar system. So it’s not just like one Earth’s resources. That’s right. One planet’s resources. Yes, you’re right. That’s more accurate. But like one planet’s full resources are being harnessed. A type three civilization, like in theory. And true. Sorry, I keep coming back. That’s fine.
Carl Youngblood
But the type one, we’re not even fully there yet in the sense that like, say nuclear energy, for example. We’re not fully utilizing even the resources in our own planet in a way that is still harmonious with the natural order and things like that.
Barrett Burgin
Yes, that’s right. So because these things are theoretically possible and a type three civilization, I mean, you have to think about time and movement and like, could that be organized? But my point is that like some of the concepts in kind of speculative science are consistent to me with theological concepts. Like, it’s sort of like the Book of Mormon says like, ‘Oh, then is this not, is not this thing true, right? Is this not true? Like, is this, does this not sort of fit the descriptions?’
Barrett Burgin
All these biblical descriptions, even Latter-day Saint descriptions of the cosmos and like worlds without number have I created and populated and this ongoing plan of salvation. This is why I like the infinite regress model quite a bit more. Is it’s like only the Milky Way, only the Milky Way and Andromeda, if we want to, if we want to expand it on a tiny scale in the vastness of, of the observable universe, like overwhelmingly qualifies for the descriptions of worlds without number of, of you can’t even count the stars. But to me, they’re numbered, right?
Barrett Burgin
Right.
Carl Youngblood
So even if you don’t even know about all the other galaxies that are out there, even that at that scale is sufficient to provoke absolute awe and wonder.
Barrett Burgin
Yes.
Barrett Burgin
And, and absolute like infinity essentially it’s, it’s innumerable and, and, and people get hung up on these like, ‘Oh, but like, you know, is God all powerful or omnibus?’ Like we have these superlatives, right? The fact that like ancient prophets are looking at the cosmos and cannot conceive of it. And that, that the, the, these two galaxies or even one galaxy absolutely qualify for this is, you know, the time it takes for the light to move from, from one end of, let’s just say one of the galaxies to the other, a new star could have been formed. Is, is this not endless as the Doctrine Covenant say?
Carl Youngblood
And so even in our own solar system, like it takes what, 20 minutes to get to Mars or something like that.
Barrett Burgin
That’s right.
Barrett Burgin
So like combine that with Joseph Smith famously saying that like, ‘I want to be resurrected with the saints. And if, if we all go to hell, we will turn the devils out and make a heaven out of it.’ The idea that if it can be done, it will be done. And if it will be done, it has been done. And if it has been done, then we are living in a plan of salvation in an endless generation of gods. And the fabric and the design of the universe attests to the shape of story, to the shape of morality, to good and evil worlds without an, ad infinitum, ad nauseum.
Barrett Burgin
And so to me, like when I think about that, it really reinforces my faith in, in sort of this, this pairing of hard scientific concepts and not for their own sake, not just because I like sci-fi, but because that’s, that is the material of discovery.
Barrett Burgin
You know, it’s like, is there archeological evidence of the Book of Mormon? Not that we found; there might not be any. It doesn’t matter to me because when I study Iain McGilchrist or when I study Jonathan Haidt, or when I look at like the way the mind works or the sociology works or the, the, the metaphysics works and how metaphysics like contradict themselves there, I see theology there. I see like something that’s so incomprehensible, and it doesn’t matter if we can comprehend it. It’s, it’s amazing. It’s miraculous. It’s not what we thought, that it leaves room in my view for the application of theological principles that seem to hold up, that seem to work.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. I think that some other interesting things you’re pointing at here are something we sometimes call the concept of forthtelling and its difference from foretelling or prediction. So in our tradition, we refer to the gift of prophecy, right? It’s not merely this ability to sort of predict the future. In fact, that’s sort of a weak form of prophecy, but rather the ability to create the future, the ability to articulate a vision so compelling that others want to make it real.
Carl Youngblood
I think this is deeply tied into science fiction. We have numerous examples of authors who first articulated a concept that later became reality. And one of the most famous ones is Arthur C. Clarke’s concept of the satellite, which are now, you know, all strewn about our planet, orbiting the planet, you know? And these are things that first had to be thought of before someone would go to the effort of trying to make them real. We also have like Leonardo da Vinci drawing sketches of flying machines, you know, centuries before humanity ever had the ability to fully realize them.
Carl Youngblood
So when you talk about these futures or these concepts, even from our past and our mythology that had to be that way, I think part of what you’re getting at is this notion that humanity drives these stories. We don’t merely just randomly select what we’re going to research, what we’re going to develop. We do it because it provokes something deep within our imagination that is guiding us long before we ever get close to realizing it.
Barrett Burgin
Yes, that’s well put. And like, I think that there’s a relationship between that and revelation, between envisionment and, like, that is practicing godhood. And I don’t think it means there’s no external source. It’s like the bicameral mind is an interesting explanation for the voices of the gods. It doesn’t mean that that’s not the voices of the gods. It doesn’t. Just because you can materially explain something does not now mean that you’re not just explaining what is an element of godhood.
Barrett Burgin
I mean, we’re looking at this with the development of scientific, like, discovery and innovation. And, you know, I’m sure you’re familiar with the uploaded mind of the fly and, you know, what AI is doing. I don’t think. I feel very strongly in a different direction that, like, we cannot Tower of Babel our way into pure revelation, into the knowledge of the divine, which is so expansive. But just because it is expansive does not mean it’s unknowable. It just means that clearly the gap is so large that the humility and the need for faith and those principles and that moral fiber, it used to be more counterintuitive to me as a younger man.
Barrett Burgin
And I’m just like, what is the utility of this when we should be learning about these things? And yet the older I get, the more I see how interconnected they are, that it’s like these actions you do over here are completely connected to this over here. And by walking away from something, you’re walking toward it. Like, it sounds paradoxical, but it’s within kind of, these are kind of self-evident laws of nature, of wisdom, of humanity, of faith. And so, so that’s where I want to be very clear that, like, it’s not a sort of rationalization of the sort of opportunity that, that Mormonism provides to make it whatever you want. I find that when you actually dig and interrogate, it is so consistent with the larger scope and the problem.
Barrett Burgin
And this is where story comes in. And this is why I’m such a major advocate for breaking out of the prisms that we build for ourselves of, kind of, it has to be this way. And this is how we look at it. You know, these are, these are bigger concepts, but, but, but just starting with good and evil, with, with the concept that something can be nuanced and that it can be gray and that within the gray, there is also just good and evil. And, and sometimes it’s not sort of what you think.
Barrett Burgin
And that by, like, for example, that, like, confronting fear is an expression of faith, and not confronting fear and closing your ears and not, not hearing anything that might challenge your faith, faith is an expression of fear. Like, like, those that go in opposite directions. Faith is the terror of facing the pit. It’s not the safety of staying in the Garden of Eden. That’s not faith. Yeah. And, uh, or, or staying in the, in the premortal life.
Barrett Burgin
And so I am a major advocate of looking at the precedent that’s already set for how we tell stories, how we engage with concepts that challenge us, doing so from a narrative place. And so that’s why, you know, I, I talk about horror a lot. It’s because it’s like, I mean, you, I know you’re a, you’re a major advocate for, like, thinking about the future and futurism and science fiction and in, in a way that is, that is hopeful rather than so cynical and so kind of dystopian. Yeah. You know, we, we, we always seem to go there.
Barrett Burgin
I, I would, all I would add to that is that I think it’s actually kind of necessary to look at the, the, you know, we talk about the Lovecraftian cosmic horror. Why is it called cosmic horror? Because the cosmos is horrifying, because the natural world, the natural, like, dark, Darwinistic, kind of dog eat dog, survival of the fittest world. Like, truly, the, the chaos of the universe is horror. It’s horrifying. And I’m a firm believer that you have to look into the, the dark to, to suddenly be able to conceive of the light. I mean, that’s very consistent with Latter-day Saint theology.
Barrett Burgin
And that when you look at concepts like grace and atonement and self-sacrifice, rather than sacrificing the weak, that’s the animalistic thing, right? It’s like, we’re going to, we’re going to leave the runt so that the strong can survive, so that we can push the gene pool forward. Then you have God intervene, and it’s all these opposite concepts that go against entropy, that…
Carl Youngblood
Care for the one.
Barrett Burgin
Yes.
Carl Youngblood
Care for the downtrodden.
Barrett Burgin
Uh-huh. That’s right. Like empathy, self-sacrifice, grace, putting, putting the, the needs of the individual, like sacrificing the needs of the individual that the, you know, planting a tree that you’ll never harvest, you know, how human is that? And to me, because that goes so against so much of what nature is, so much of what our technological comforts protect us from, then you have this interesting dichotomy. You have this interesting relationship where the technology is getting in its own way because we can’t, we won’t let ourselves conceive of the terror that might be the reality in order to grapple with it and confront it and overcome it. I hope that makes sense.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. In fact, I would say that perhaps part of what it means to be created in the image of God as humanity, as individuals as well, is our capacity to take the natural world as we find it and bend it towards greater justice, towards greater harmony, towards greater union. And in fact, when we see some of the aspects of nature that we dislike or that we want to avoid and try to shape it in a direction that seems more harmonious, more conducive to our goals, by doing that in certain ways, depending on how we do it, we could be actually taking a godlike approach, taking, as it says, dominion over creation.
Barrett Burgin
Absolutely. Or stewardship, if you want to, if you prefer that. That’s right. Right? Yeah, that’s right.
Barrett Burgin
And it is idealistic. You know, I start to speak this way and people who sort of read between the lines when I’m thinking about the City of Enoch and no poor among us. And I don’t mean, you know, I’m not talking about Marxism. I’m not even talking about strictly free market capitalism. It’s something else, like these ideas that the early Latter-day Saints had that do abandon those things, though, that like put the need of the community, which heaven within Mormonism is all community.
Carl Youngblood
We’re social beings.
Barrett Burgin
Yes. That exaltation is not individual. It cannot be. Salvation can be. And you need to build on the individual. And again, that’s kind of the monomyth, right? It’s like the self is on this quest, but the end always ends with atonement. It always ends with, like, the destruction of the self for all. And ironically, by doing so comes exaltation.
Barrett Burgin
And so we think about these kind of idealistic principles where people will, again, they’ll become afraid. And they’re like, ‘Well, that’s very idealistic. That’s very unrealistic. You got to kind of, you know, grapple with things as they are.’ It’s like a practical.
Barrett Burgin
Of course you do, you know, but so was, so was agriculture. You know, it’s like if you look at how long we were hunter gatherers compared to we just started, we just barely started agriculture. And look what’s happened. It’s exponential. And so, like, it’s hard. It’s not easy. It’s not, you know, that’s, salvation is not a cheap experience, as President Holland said. So it takes work and the miraculous. It takes the divine. It takes the complete transformation of the self.
Barrett Burgin
And what is, what is so incredible is that it can work. It does work, like agriculture and civilization building did work, and not without a lot of pain and conquering. And, you know, and you look at something sort of algorithmically, like when it comes to permutations or something of something, I mean, like you’re going to have lots and lots and lots of failed experiments until it, until it catches and then it builds on itself, you know, and that, that’s kind of what’s happening with iterative, you know, technology. And so anyway, I hope this isn’t all too heavy. I feel like you totally understand.
Carl Youngblood
We’re diving right into it. This is like meaty stuff. I love it. I love it. This is perfect.
Barrett Burgin
But like one last addendum is like to tie it back to what I do as a filmmaker, like story and talking about things in this way and simplifying those concepts and applying those concepts to what we consider the gospel, which at least doctrinally, we believe encompasses all truth, all scientific truth, all historical, all philosophical, even other faiths. I feel like culturally we as Latter-day Saints often kind of draw this line and we keep shrinking it too. It’s like, it’s like how, how much of a particular Old Testament chapter can we cut out until we’re finally on a single, like kind of, you know, um, digestible, easy, digestible verse, you know, that, that is, that is a platitude and it’s nice and it’s true. And there’s a lot of wisdom.
Barrett Burgin
And I say that and I would contradict myself to, you know, you, you can mid rash around something and it’s like, oh, there’s so much to pull, but you’re missing the larger context by not confronting the things that make us all uncomfortable. And I’m like, how, what are we doing? How is that not the opposite of circumscribing all things and bringing them in and, you know, as comfortably talking about a Dyson sphere as you are with, you know, the Pearl of Great Price and the glory of the sun and the moon and the planets all having this order and system? And it’s like, what is that? You know, rather than trying to get at like, well, what could Joseph Smith possibly mean that we can fit into what makes us comfortable?
Barrett Burgin
It’s like, how about we ask, what could that mean based on our evolving discovery? And, and how, how can we take those myths, those glyphs, those symbols and let them stand like Colab? You’ve got something about Colab right over there. Colab’s amazing. Colab’s the best thing that ever happened to us when it comes to the cosmos. And yet we’re so weird about it. We’re so like, ‘Oh, don’t talk about Colab,’ you know, like, like we don’t want people to know that’s our planet, you know, star based Colab. And it’s like, yeah.
Carl Youngblood
Or else you have some mockery in the, you know, general public about stuff like this. But, you know, it’s, it’s so interesting that you bring this up because recently a good friend, mutual friend of ours, who’s also doing some work for us, Jaxon Washburn, talked about the absence of late of the mythopoetic register in Mormonism, in our culture, in our discourse. Right. And he shared some beautiful, you know, images that kind of provoke these, this more adventurous concept is more exploratory way of talking about your faith. And one of the things that it reminded me of is this great saying from Alfred North Whitehead, where he said, ‘The death of religion occurs with the loss of the high hope of adventure.’ Right. So he talks about this notion of religion is an adventure of the spirit and that it needs to be inspiring, thought provoking, awe, you know, commanding. And so I think that you’re hitting on something really important here.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah. Mythic, if you will, you know, the monomyth, the hero with a thousand faces and, and ancient, you know, look, look, look how much the, you know, the Odyssey resonated with everyone. I have a friend, I have a friend who, who saw it and he liked it. Okay. But he was like, “I saw it. It, it just, it didn’t feel, you know, it didn’t feel very original. It felt like stuff we’ve seen before.” And I’m like, “Well, it is the oldest story, you know, so like, let’s cut it some slack, but we want that. We crave that.”
Carl Youngblood
Be sure to check out our Transfigurist artwork series with posters, framed prints, puzzles, and apparel portraying inspiring glimpses of what future pioneers might achieve in a vibrant retrofuturist style. Buy them on our website at transfigurism.org/store. Every purchase helps us to make more of this kind of quality content. The other most important thing you can do to show your support is to like and subscribe and leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. Now, back to the show.
Carl Youngblood
And so we seem to love exploring and writing about this stuff in certain contexts, right? In movie making or in, in fiction. And I’m curious, I mean, I have plenty of ideas, but I’d love to hear yours about why we seem to have been so prolific in that way and why we maybe don’t feel quite as comfortable bringing it into Sunday school or whatever.
Barrett Burgin
So I, I think that there’s a reason Jaxon posted those images and they blew up and people loved them and shared them. It’s like we’re missing something. Yes. On a fundamental level, we’re craving it.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. Yeah.
Barrett Burgin
People generally crave this. Latter-day Saints crave it in particular.
Carl Youngblood
I mean, all of these posters, in fact, like we were talking at the beginning of this about this whole new Transfigurist artwork series that we’re building. And it seemed to resonate with you as well. And, you know, part of why we’re doing that is because we want to remind our fellow Latter-day Saints of some of the grand visions that we have, right?
Barrett Burgin
That’s right. Yep. That’s that we have. And, and, and it’s still within us. Like when I went on Informed Saints and talked about D&C 129 and the handshake test and, and how it’s in my view, fundamentally intrinsically tied to the temple and that deception and truth and, you know, truth and error and the satanic and the divine and sort of this, this very interesting kind of dualism. And you see it all throughout the scriptures where it’s like Satan is the counterfeit of God.
Barrett Burgin
It can make us a little bit uncomfortable because it feels so mystic. It feels so esoteric. And yet so many people were like, “Ah, yeah, you know, it’s still canonized doctrinal idea.” And of course we’re talking about it in sort of these literal ways, you know, and, and I guess for anyone listening, it’s the idea that if a, if a supernatural being or an angelic messenger appears to you, you, you do this sort of a test by gripping their hand and depending on what you do or do not feel, you know, whether or not they are a true messenger.
Carl Youngblood
And just to catch the audience up, this featured in one of your recent films.
Barrett Burgin
So maybe if you could give us a two second quick explanation of that. If you’re watching, please, please check out The Angel on ALTER on YouTube. ALTER is the biggest YouTube shorts distributor. I think less than 2% of films that are submitted to it get in and they reached out to us because they were like, “We’ve never seen anything like this.” This is unique. It’s peculiar. It’s, it’s, it’s what we have and it just fascinates people.
Barrett Burgin
And yet I’ll answer that question just a little bit more in a moment, which I, what I think keeps us back from it, but it not only resonated with non-member audiences who found it intriguing and fascinating, but, but Latter-day Saints were so, it felt so alive. And I had so many messages sent to my wife, Jessica and I who directed it together were like, “Thank you for doing this. I feel so like this is such a fundamental part of my religious identity and history and it’s unique and it’s interesting. And I feel like we’re not allowed to talk about this, you know, culturally, we kind of put guardrails around, around what we talk about.” And anyway, I did this, this episode with Informed Saints and there was such an interesting reaction. A lot of evangelical Christians dogpiled and were like, “No, but I don’t think it’s about like necessarily disagreeing with some supernatural concept that’s completely consistent with the absurdities all throughout the Bible.”
Carl Youngblood
Well, it’s also really funny how each of the groups, whether they’re critics or supporters, it’s just kind of like examining it on a different level of literalness, right? And no, I’m about to get to that. Yeah.
Barrett Burgin
But that they didn’t like that it was legitimized in any way. Oh, I see. It’s the legitimacy, continually, I go back to this. I think the problem is sociological. I think the problem is sort of preferred politics of in-group politics and like we cannot legitimize Mormonism, you know, in any capacity, even though there’s the best kind of takedown of this is to point to how consistent it is with all biblical kind of ideas that are absurd, you know, that are hard to wrap our minds around.
Carl Youngblood
Well, it’s even funny that sometimes when both sides of these kind of debates agree on everything, they still think one is wrong and one is right. You know what I’m saying?
Barrett Burgin
Exactly.
Carl Youngblood
It’s like more of a, almost a difference in temperament of the person, whether they’re on one side or the other.
Barrett Burgin
Precisely. And they make the same arguments at each other. But the way I wanted to talk about it is that it’s like, we have to engage with this as a sort of literal physical metaphor. Do we not already do that with ordinances? Why don’t we just sign a piece of paper for Pete’s sake? If we’re going to promise to follow Christ, why all this hullabaloo about getting in water and why all of this, you know, eating things and dressing up? It’s like, I made this point to somebody as we were talking about kind of the ordinances and their evolution and when symbol maintains significance versus its, you know, efficiency. It’s like, well, the most efficient thing we could do is just go ahead and get the paper out and say, “I do here agree.”
Carl Youngblood
And yeah, well, and not, not to disparage any other faiths, but there are some that actually believe that merely turning, for example, a wheel in which a prayer is written has some efficacy, right?
Barrett Burgin
Sure. Of course.
Carl Youngblood
And yet there are many others, including our own, you know, theology that would disagree with that concept, right? And so it’s, it’s quite interesting to see how different groups land in different registers here.
Barrett Burgin
But even, even the act of doing something, the symbolic function. Yeah. That’s what I’m getting at is like, why have it at all? Because we need symbols, we need visuals, we need myths, whether they’re literal or not, and they might be. But when it came to talking about this angel thing, to me, it was much more valuable to think about this as a professor Alonzo Gaskill at BYU talks about like, well, no, we can read this, this test as an extension of signifiers in the temple of whether or not you can trust information. And then all of a sudden it becomes very complimentary with the idea of discerning truth from error. What a great lesson. What an interesting lesson.
Barrett Burgin
What a, what a more interesting way, in my opinion, to think about like when Joseph Smith thinks about the demonic or is describing the demonic. It is not so much of like correct belief or correct, like, okay, this is a devilish object and this is a nice, safe Christian, you know, a nice, safe Christian magical stick that parts the water versus a devilish stone that shows you things. He talks about these things and how they’re utilized. And he talks about seer stones and like how they can be corrupted or this, this fantastical bizarre experience with, with casting out Satan. These things are in church history. And what is so bizarre is how Joseph talks about it or thinks about it. He’s like, ‘I don’t know yet. We need to find out,’ as if something can be used as two sides of the same coin.
Barrett Burgin
And then, and then I think about that and I’m like, is that not true? Is that not kind of a true principle in application that, you know, this test of testing angels becomes very functional and philosophical when you think about it in terms of knowledge, in terms of good information versus bad information and good information, like true information, inherently being good and false information inherently being bad? And now you’ve, you’ve got sort of a, like a moralizing of the thing.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. I hope that makes sense. I think it does, in application.
Carl Youngblood
Maybe something I could add to this is that you have this notion, and that William James sometimes articulated, of living options, right? For each generation, what they believe in and their worldview and what’s already been discovered and proven and widely demonstrated influences what they think of as plausible or not, right? And so in Joseph Smith’s generation, you’re going to have a different register of what’s plausible and what’s not versus ours.
Carl Youngblood
And in the same way, the theologian Paul Tillich talks about how symbols of faith wax and wane, depending on the generation and its reactions to them. And so, you know, in an era where, say, monarchy is the primary system of government, when you refer to the savior of the world as the king of kings, that symbol registers so strongly as a person to whom all the, a leader to whom all the other leaders of this world are subject, right? And yet in an era of like greater egalitarianism and democracy, the symbol of monarchy slightly weakens because we no longer have that same relationship with it, right? So the types of registers, the types of imagery, the types of stories that we tell each other have different resonance depending on what our awareness is and what our position within the culture is, right?
Barrett Burgin
Well, that’s a really interesting perspective. And I hadn’t really thought about that before in terms of like maybe the pushback, the reticence that we get internally from, from dealing with some of these things that seem odd, that seem weird.
Carl Youngblood
And I mean, if you showed some of these scenes to, I don’t know, some ancient inhabitants of the world, they might have no idea where they’re even looking.
Barrett Burgin
Right. They don’t know what they’re seeing. The one piece I would add to your, to your earlier question of like kind of getting away from it is I, I do think, I do think cultural shame plays a part. I think there is a long history and I’ve been talking about this more and more. The more I think about it, the more I write about it, the more I kind of dig is why do these things resonate with people? Because subconsciously they’re there, they’re there within Mormonism. It’s Mormon doctrine, history, theology, it’s Latter-day Saint ideology.
Barrett Burgin
You know, we all like know these stories, you know, I don’t have to say very much about the handshake test with an angel for any Latter-day Saint who knows anything about anything to go, ‘Oh yeah, I know this. Like, I’ve heard, I’ve heard of this.’ We don’t really study it. We don’t go back to it. We don’t apply it the way we just did, the way we talk about it. Not very often. We sometimes kind of make it very literal and like, ‘Yeah, I guess, you know, whatever Joseph was at.’ Like, Jasmine even asked the question on the interview, like, ‘Does this have any relevance for us today?’ And for me, I’m like, it has enormous relevance.
Barrett Burgin
It is so integral to all of these symbols and glyphs that are getting at a, you know, a greater truth, but that’s on the subconscious level that I think we all kind of believe that and want that. And it’s the same thing where it’s like Jaxon posting those pictures. They just resonate. There’s a hunger for it. There’s a craving for it. I think on the conscious level, there is shame around these things. And there is such a long generational history of not really fitting in to the broader culture.
Carl Youngblood
There’s also, I think, a bureaucratic impulse, right? Where if someone’s in charge of organizing a large group of people, they’re like, ‘You know, we don’t need all that messy stuff. Like, let’s just stick to these.’
Barrett Burgin
But even the bureaucratic impulse, I think, is inherited from, you know, the Edmunds Tucker Act and the Reed Smoot hearings and the assimilation of the 20th century. And then cozying up with, you know, you know, Elder Joseph Fielding Smith kind of cozying up to the other Christian ideas of the day about evolution. And that didn’t originate with us. It’s like we’re grabbing all these things.
Barrett Burgin
I want to be really clear. I said this earlier. I love other faith traditions. I love the rest of Christianity. I find so much wisdom and truth in it, as we should, you know, and as we have a warmth to it.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah, we’re supposed to be gathering these truths.
Barrett Burgin
Of course. Conversely, I deeply resent and reject the need to assimilate within, the need to get credibility or legitimacy from the other Christian traditions. A lot of the, what Joseph Smith referred to as sectarian notions that I agree with, that there are theological differences that they would highlight and I would highlight to say, ‘Yeah, no, I do kind of lean this way.’ Yeah, sometimes we almost want it both ways, right?
Carl Youngblood
Where our tradition begins with a rejection of some creedal notions and even a declaration that they are an abomination in some ways, right? And yet we crave acceptance and legitimacy. We crave a kind of validation from these same parties because they have some degree of power, whatever it happens to be. Yes. Acceptance, wider, you know, whatever it is. But we probably shouldn’t, we should probably examine that and say, ‘Well, why do we want this both ways, right?’
Barrett Burgin
I don’t think it serves them. I don’t think it serves us. I found just kind of anecdotally in my religious expression growing up in the Southeast, that when I just kind of owned my Mormonism and was proud of it and was curious about other faiths. And I like, you know, I went to Seder with my Jewish friend every year we would, I’d participate in Passover, not the seminary derivative version. I mean, like an actual Passover meal, you know, I attended mosque, all of my friends that I’d sit with at the lunch table were Baptist and Presbyterian and Methodist and Catholic. And we would discuss religion.
Barrett Burgin
And I would make a very strong case for like, ‘No, like there, there’s no question that sociologically and kind of academically, like we are Christian, we’re an expression of Christianity as much as Gnosticism is a valid expression of Christianity.’ Like we have to look at this, you know, like grownups, but also respect and say, ‘There are differences and you’re right to point them out. Let me explain what they are. And you kind of decide for yourself and I’m not going to diminish your view.’
Barrett Burgin
And I think there’s beauty. I think there’s a lot of beauty to the Trinity. I think there’s a lot of, when properly understood, I think there’s a lot of beauty to kind of the individual, the fallen individual that can do nothing and in God’s mercy and love, like totally extends that. It’s, you know, you know, we don’t have a workspace theology, but there is, there is absolutely the co-creators with God and God in his majesty is creating beings like himself. That’s different.
Barrett Burgin
And I think in my experience that I, I, I got more respect, like they respected that I was a Mormon boy when we were Mormons and that I was proud of that. And they also would sometimes say, ‘You do love Jesus Christ. Like I’ve, I’ve, I’ve come to, I’ve come to see that, you know.’ And I’m like, ‘I do. And I, and I don’t need you to tell me that I do, you know.’ And so I’m going on that as well.
Carl Youngblood
I think it’s quite interesting that from a missionary perspective, you know, if we’re, if we emphasize our similarity constantly and mostly just focus on that, it strikes me that for anyone who already is coming from a larger Christian background, they would probably ask themselves, ‘Well, what do I need from you?’
Barrett Burgin
Absolutely.
Carl Youngblood
So in some ways our distinctiveness might actually be more of our, uh, something worth touting and a strength worth showcasing, right?
Barrett Burgin
It’s what we have to offer. And, and, and both parties can respect each other more when one is not constantly trying to seek approval from, from the other. I mean, this is just classic, like, you know, you know, nobody, nobody really wants the, the desperate trailing along, like, ‘Please like me.’ Yeah. You know, it’s, it’s somebody who. It’s so uncool. It’s uncool. It’s someone who knows who they are. Like, that’s why I lean into the esotericism.
Barrett Burgin
And so the bureaucratic impulse, while I’m sympathetic to it, I, I legitimately call, like, I think it all comes from generational inherited trauma. Yeah. Yeah. And this is why I will poke this just to, just to prove a point sometimes, even in, I have, I have great relationships with people who work in the institution and they know I am, I am all in, I am, I am so in the church and believe and sustain and love it. And also we’ll, we’ll make points to say, ‘Look, not only is this a criticism, we can’t even handle the criticism and here’s why. And look at this. And, and.’
Carl Youngblood
In the tech community, we say similar things where like, why did we decide to call it Silicon slopes here in Utah rather than like Deseret something? I don’t know. Like we could have done something more distinctive, but we’re just copycatting everything that came from the secular culture.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah. Right. That’s right. And so we can’t where, I think there’s a lot of tension as a Latter-day Saints amongst ourselves. There’s always tension. And I think that tension, James Goldberg wrote about this in a beautiful review of my film Java Jive, which is a comedy, but it’s about something. It’s, it’s making a comment. It’s a, it’s a pointed finger at ourselves and, and not for how weird we are for not drinking coffee, for how weird we are for being so weird about not drinking coffee. When there are so many religious groups that have, you know, arguably kind of, uh, what’s the word I’m looking for?
Carl Youngblood
Just as weird things.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah. Yeah.
Carl Youngblood
Like, like, or their own idiosyncrasies, whatever they have.
Barrett Burgin
Well, even, even health codes that are arbitrary. That’s what I’m looking for. That are, that are like, like arguably arbitrary from a, from a, from a, from a, from a scientific perspective. And yet they’re important. They’re, they’re symbols. And so, um, James calls it, you know, the, you know, Jewish people write about this and kind of call it a shame to the Gentiles. It’s like, you’re making us look bad, you know, don’t, you know, the Gentiles, like they, they could team up and kill us. And so don’t embarrass us in front of the other people. And I think, I think Latter-day Saints operate with some of this.
Carl Youngblood
It resonates because we also have a persecution complex, right?
Barrett Burgin
Uh-huh. You know? Yeah. And it, and it comes from a real place. It’s also striking that their population of the Jewish culture is roughly similar to ours. Yes, that’s right.
Carl Youngblood
Population size.
Barrett Burgin
And I really do think that the, that then we have these competing subconscious and conscious. And so we don’t let ourselves totally go there. And yet, you know, like any repressed desire, it comes out even stronger when it’s like, no, but that’s, that’s, that is, this is what we believe. This is what we think. This is the stuff that keeps people in the church. This is the stuff that people want and crave.
Carl Youngblood
So how do we come into our own here?
Barrett Burgin
Yeah. Yeah.
Carl Youngblood
And what are your thoughts around that?
Barrett Burgin
Well, I, I.
Carl Youngblood
Is there a moment where we’re going to like, just more fully assume the, the stature of Mormon-ness, I guess?
Barrett Burgin
Oh, that’s such a beautiful question. I mean, I have no idea, but at least in my part, people ask a lot, like, are you, so you’re, are you a Latter-day Saint filmmaker? I don’t, I don’t like that moniker, not because I, if it’s not obvious, I’m completely unashamed of the gospel, but because I think, I think it sort of suggests a sort of, like, it comes with some baggage. It’s like, I’m, I’m, I’m a Latter-day Saint who makes LDS movies for LDS people. That’s not true.
Barrett Burgin
I make, I make my movies. I do more than that. Like the, the, the films I have made have wider distribution and yet they’re so Mormon in their DNA. How can that be? Because it is the very thing that appeals to people by. Ironically, by being more specific, we’re more universal. By being less specific, by being generic, we’re weirder.
Carl Youngblood
We’re, we’re, we’re back to Judaism here. We have some classic examples of stories from Judaism that just went viral and global. And so, yeah, why can’t that happen with other traditions?
Barrett Burgin
And people read stories and watch movies about something different than themselves because it’s different than themselves. And, and ironically, you see more of yourself in something that is a bit different because it’s, again, it’s universal. Specific, it’s these paradoxes. The novelty helps you perceive things you have not ordinarily perceived, right? To be specific is to be universal. To try to be universal is to be generic and unspecific and unrelatable.
Barrett Burgin
And so when we downplay it, and so like for me, my hope to your, your, to answer your question is to contribute in telling those stories and trying to reach wider audiences and being unashamed of the specificity and the conflict, the inner conflict, but ultimately coming from a place that is not so reductionist. That’s so boring to me that the, the reductionist, and I, I don’t mean to disparage, but kind of the, the, the ex-Mormon tendency to me is to, is to get caught along the way. And it’s not to come out of the other side, but I do think that it’s important to look into the pit of darkness and go like, okay, how do we confront the fear?
Barrett Burgin
And so that’s, that’s to me, if there was going to be a sort of watershed shift for, for Latter-day Saints culturally, it will come when we finally come into our own and accept what we are and embrace what we are rather than trying to be something else. And ironically, by accepting what it is and what we are, we have all the room in the world to evolve and to grow and to, to change. And so I, you know, hopefully that makes sense.
Carl Youngblood
I think so. In fact, one additional thing that strikes me as you’re describing this is that a lot of those tendencies you say on the ex-Mormon side to get stuck on some of the claims that you no longer believe in and on, maybe we could call it this, um, bureaucratic tendency to focus on more of the literal claims. They’re sort of foils for one another, right? Yeah. Um, both sides are, you know, sort of doubling down on, well, this is what it’s supposed to be. Right. And therefore I rejected it or therefore I embrace it. But either way, it’s sort of like this insistence on not allowing other valences and other registers to be present and to be, um, observed.
Barrett Burgin
Exactly. That’s so well put. And, and they’re, they are two, kind of two sides of the same coin. Often it’s, it’s a similar disposition that finds itself on either side. I find that a lot of my friends who’ve left the church, not everyone, I do not mean to mischaracterize, but I’m not, I’m not going to sugarcoat it. Like I get tired of this kind of, you know. Yeah.
Carl Youngblood
I mean, I have friends on both sides as well.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah. And, and dancing. Most of us do these days. That’s right. Most of us do.
Barrett Burgin
And, and I find that friends on both sides really appreciate the art I’m making because it’s just, it’s not, it’s, it’s not trying to be didactic. It’s not appealing to one or the other. It’s just, it’s just honest. And for people on both sides are uncomfortable with it. Like the angel absolutely grapples with plural marriage in a way that has surprised everyone in a way that it’s like, “Oh, we think we know what this is going to be.” And then by the end, it’s like, “So what are you actually saying?” And it’s like, “What do you, it’s like, whose side are you on?”
Carl Youngblood
And that’s like, that’s the productive question.
Barrett Burgin
You know, you’ll have one group that’s like, “I don’t like that you made this because it’s uncomfortable. So you must be on the other side.” And then I’ll have another group that’s like, “I don’t like what maybe the film is asking. You must be on the other side.” And it’s like, “Well, I am definitely on a side, but the, that’s not the point of art.” The art is meant to ask questions and to find itself somewhere in the middle that allows the viewer to engage with and think about and critically examine these things.
Barrett Burgin
And so similarly, when I talk about this, I find that like some of the questions offend both sides on the same basis because it’s, it’s like, “Well, you’re, you’re seriously engaging with it. Don’t you know, we do polemics here? Like polemics is safe, you know?” And it’s like, but that’s not theology. Theology is the very opposite of that. Theology is to do, is to emulate, you know, Moses or Jesus Christ or Joseph Smith or Muhammad for that matter, like to ask questions, to, to wrestle and be tortured by the vastness of the possibility and the expanse.
Barrett Burgin
And so it’s not to diminish the questions of materialism, but I can have the same frustrations with the bureaucracy or with the culture and not have it need to sort of like those things can be mutually exclusive. It doesn’t mean that because of these frustrations or because of this intensity, it must therefore mean that this, this, this, this, this, this, and this, it’s the same. That’s the, that’s making the same kind of argument. It’s like, “Well, if we have this, we can believe this.” And it’s like, “No, not necessarily. It’s more complicated than that.”
Barrett Burgin
And so my expression of love for the church and the gospel is 100% to remain and, and not to try to like shape it in my own image or anything, but rather to interrogate it on its own basis and go, “Well, this is what the text says. What do we make of that? You know, is that authoritative or not?” And authoritative, I think is a more productive word than literal. That’s, that’s not as interesting, but like to your question, you know, or your, your comment earlier, like maybe the answer’s no, but it’s worth asking. And it’s especially worth asking in the context of all that we see and know, and maybe aren’t willing to think about in a, in a, in a broader perspective.
Barrett Burgin
So, you know, and that, that’s dangerous. It’s dangerous to act, to come up to the, you know, to the, to the gap, to the Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade coming up to the, the chasm and taking a step, that’s dangerous. And is that not an act of faith? You know, faith is danger. Fear is, is, is safe.
Carl Youngblood
So if I could also explore another adjacent topic here, one of the things that I think about as we talk about storytelling and different ways of telling stories is how Brigham Young felt it so important to bring theater to, to the early Mormon pioneer culture. And even went so far as to say that we need to see depicted both light and dark. We need to see depicted both negative and positive, and that we wouldn’t necessarily be damaged by the experience of some of those negative portrayals. And so obviously that applies specifically to a lot of the work you’re doing, but I, I want to also tie into this question before I hand it over to you that lately we’ve had so much excess of dystopia.
Barrett Burgin
Sure.
Carl Youngblood
And so I’d love for you to talk to about both of these topics, about both why it’s important for us to see sometimes negative portrayals or fear or horror, those kinds of things, but also then why the balance at the moment seems so out of whack towards dystopia.
Barrett Burgin
Okay. Well, I think it’s like, like I’ve mentioned earlier, I think it’s very, very important to confront darkness. You know, that’s something that Brigham Young talked about. It’s, it’s consistent with scripture. No one ever has a good answer for me when they, you know, kind of come at me and like, ‘Why did you make this horror film?’ And, you know, ‘You’re talking about polygamy and, and, and demons, and this is satanic. We shouldn’t be, we shouldn’t be even discussing this.’
Barrett Burgin
And I’m like, ‘Okay, well then why is it all over the New Testament? Why is it the first happening in the entire restoration is Satan attacks Joseph Smith, and only then does God and do God and Christ appear, and the contrast is made?’ It’s in Second Nephi two that talks about Shakespeare, it’s all over Shakespeare, but limiting it just to a Latter-day Saint kind of ethos, if you will, is very productive because you can point to all of the ways that it’s like, ‘This is, this is foundational.’
Barrett Burgin
I am also of the opinion, especially when it comes to, we’ll call it the cosmic horror, the worry that things are maybe way worse than we even are willing to let our minds go there. Like with the Epstein files, for example, nobody wants to talk about this. It’s like, we all kind of peered into the void and then closed it. And it’s like, ‘Well, whatever that is, you know?’ And it’s like, ‘Well, wait a minute, guys, like, this is, this is fundamental. This is, this is the, this are, these are the building blocks that everything’s built on.’ It, it’s proverbial. It’s like digging under your foundation and finding there’s bones everywhere. And it’s like, ‘Oh my gosh, like, you know, painted over the, the painted over the dome is, is all the horror and all the stuff we did to build this.’
Barrett Burgin
And so I’m of the opinion that to be ignorant to evil, to darkness, to, you know, to wickedness, to use these Latter-day Saint terms, but just to the dark or the negative or the potentially, you know, duplicitous or deceiving is to necessarily uphold it. It is, it is to be, you know, to be complacent is basically to uphold it by accident because you’re not willing to look at it. And so then you are, you know, you’re a participant in it through, through ignorance. It’s like evil and power, you know, misapplied is counting on that. It’s always counting on the fact that you won’t, you, you won’t look too hard, and that’s scriptural, right?
Barrett Burgin
And so like from just an ethical perspective, it’s like, how, how can you treat a problem if you’re not willing to confront it? How, how can you, you know, if, if you’re sort of complacent in the thing, how, how are you able to, to dream and to overcome because it’s sort of playing into the mirage that all is well in Zion? Yay, Zion prospereth, all is well.
Barrett Burgin
And balancing that with not being a, a sort of doomsday, ‘It’s all going to fall apart.’ One of my favorite scenes in, in any movie is in the Lord of the Rings in the Two Towers when, you know, Frodo almost gives the ring up and, and, and gives up to temptation to give the ring away to the, the Nazgul, and Sam tackles him and they fall down the stairs and Frodo draws his sword on Sam. He can feel himself changing. He can feel himself being sucked into the darkness of what’s happening in Middle Earth.
Barrett Burgin
And Sam gives this great speech about how it’s like the great stories, Mr. Frodo, here, here we come back to story, when all almost seemed lost, and he describes the darkness and how it’s like, everything’s falling. And he’s like, ‘But in those stories, they were holding onto something.’ And Frodo said, ‘Well, what were they holding onto, Sam?’ And he’s like, ‘There’s some good in this world, and it’s worth fighting for.’ And that fragile kind of kernel of good, of light, of truth grows into the great oak that becomes a Zion society, that becomes a type three civilization, becomes a city of Enoch.
Barrett Burgin
Like, like in the Bible, we have the story of, of, you know, the, the, the army coming and it’s like, ‘What will we do?’ It’s like, ‘Don’t, don’t fear not.’ The prophet says, ‘Fear not.’ The, I think it’s Elijah or Elisha, that’s, ‘Those that be with us are more than those that be with them.’ And, and so hope becomes more valuable in the face of dystopia, in the face of fear.
Barrett Burgin
And I think sometimes why we have so much dystopia, it’s almost an unrelated question, because I think, I think that when it comes to science and technology, so when it comes to religion, when it comes to evil, right, when it comes to enacted dark things, that’s the kind of stuff where it’s like, we would rather, we would rather believe that everything’s functioning kind of the way it’s supposed to. It’s all going according to the plan, you know, whether people on the other side of the world are suffering, it’s like, ‘Well, it’s the cost of keeping civilization alive.’
Barrett Burgin
When it comes to technology, I think it brings a similar threat. It’s like, ‘Well, that’s going to disrupt everything.’ And again, it comes from this need of safety. And so in some ways it’s almost scarier to imagine that technology and evolution and innovation, it will disrupt what’s already here. And so I sometimes think that dystopian stories are very comforting because it reinforces the view like, ‘Yeah, that’s bad.’ You know, we kind of want to be Luddites a little bit and like, ‘It’s always been the way it’s always been.’ And so, so either of those things you’re digging up and sort of interrogating a little bit.
Barrett Burgin
I do think that dystopia is useful as a, as a cautionary type tale because, because it is the human impulse that will corrupt things, but that’s not the technology. That’s not the innovation, you know, that’s what’s so beautiful about Mormon transhumanism is it’s like, how, how could we look at these things and not be terrified of them? Not think like, ‘Oh, this is Satan’s counterfeit to the true technology of God, which can only be revealed.’ It’s like, ‘Well, wait a minute. Then what do we do with Joseph Smith kind of trying to figure it out and work it out? And what do we do with Joseph Smith saying, “Here’s a seer stone. It can be used for good or it can be used for bad. It’s going to be used for both. We’re going to use it for good.”’?
Barrett Burgin
So anyway, I’m sorry to take it to kind of a dark place, but I, I feel like that is the, again, the, the, the only way to champion and to value and to appreciate the light. And is that not what happens proverbially to Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden? Is that not what Second Nephi two in the Pearl of Great Price provide to the false story that it’s like, ‘This is good. It’s good for you to go through these things because you’re going to learn the difference.’ And it doesn’t mean that the difference is always a binary, but it’s drifting one way.
Barrett Burgin
Or the other. And so you’ll, you’ll learn to understand and champion the sweet when you experience the bitter.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah. I think there’s also a sort of dialectic involved in all this process, which is that, um, you know, it seems like we get, we get these trends. Uh, we talked about things that were cool and uncool before. Well, at a certain level, if you’ve been telling only dystopian stories for the last 30 years, people start to get tired of it. And they’re like, ‘That’s kind of a pretty tired trope at this point. Like, can’t you, uh, move on to something else, you know?’ And so I think we go in these direct different directions, the, uh, pendulum swings one way or the other. Right.
Carl Youngblood
I would say when I look back at different eras, for example, in the fifties and sixties, especially post-war era, there was this great degree of optimism around technology and grand visions of what we might achieve. Right.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah.
Carl Youngblood
And then we, uh, ran into the oil crisis and the environmental crisis. And I think that was a sort of peeling back of maybe the worms in the wood, woodwork. Right. And then people said, you know, kind of freaked out and started to focus, especially on, um, all the things that could go wrong from this. And we might now be going through the, the trough of that, where it’s just like, you know, easier and more formulaic to just think of like all the things that could go wrong. Because like, why would there ever be anyone in a position of authority who isn’t corrupt? Or why would there ever be any organization that isn’t a secret conspiracy or cabal? Right.
Carl Youngblood
And so I, I think, um, it just becomes less, it requires less energy sometimes to come up with a more creative story. Like I often talk about, um, some of my favorite films as being those where there are no bad guys, right? Like, um, one that I often refer to is, um, Apollo 13, right? Um, there are no bad guys in that story. They’re all trying to solve the problem, but it’s still like riveting. I mean, it’s still, and it’s still full of heroism and failures and, you know, um, it, it doesn’t cease to be interesting or captivating merely because we don’t have all those tropes and elements in it. Right. And obviously there’s many different types of stories you can tell. I just point to.
Barrett Burgin
No, that’s interesting. I mean, you know, it’s not like evil or darkness needs to show up and everything. I do think that sometimes there can be a naivete when we don’t let ourselves go there, but on the flip side, God says he, you know, basically to be in the presence of God is, is light and truth and glory. And I don’t mean to turn this into any kind of like, you know, but gatekeeping or boundary keeping or whatever. But when God says he cannot look at upon sin with the least degree of allowance, I think, I think we, you know, we feel that and it feels very like, oh, you know, punishing. But the flip side to that is how exciting is the glory of God? How exciting is, is technology and human progress and human spirit and innovation. And when we have conquered, when we have overcome those things, then I think that is the, that is the ultimate side.
Barrett Burgin
You know, this 400 years conflict, conflict naturally is what we like in story. So it’s, it’s, it’s hard to get a very idealistic story because we need conflict. Apollo 13 definitely has conflict, but it’s man versus nature, you know? And so now we’re overcoming something and we’ve gotten the sort of the, the villainy out of the way, if you will.
Barrett Burgin
I think too, that it, it probably is important to grapple with the harder work of kind of telling innovative stories when it comes to, when it comes to innovation, when it comes to technology, because it’s not going to stop. This is, this is the part, you know, that with the AI conversation, there’s, there is a ton to be worried about. And there’s a ton that feels like greedy and rushed and kind of, you know, for its own sake. But if we just try to like throw the brakes on completely, then it’s going to move on whether or not we put our heads in the sand.
Carl Youngblood
And we may not have as much influence.
Barrett Burgin
That’s what I mean. That’s what I mean. Versus going, ‘Okay, well, the wheels don’t stop. So how can we think about this in a creative divine way? How can this be used for good?’ Again, going back to sort of the mystical, the mystical artifacts, is it, it’s not that there’s an artifact that’s bad. It’s how it’s being used. It’s what it’s being used for. And it will be used for bad. And maybe it will mostly be used for bad. But, you know, we’re not going to roll back the internet. You know, we’re not going to roll back the industrial revolution. Like, the cat’s out of the bag. We can look at the negative consequences, but look at everything that came from it.
Barrett Burgin
And so that is where I do think your call in particular to, to kind of think of this through the lens of hope and, and optimism and kind of utopia rather than dystopia is exactly how Latter-day Saints were thinking in the early days about building Zion. It was like, ‘What can we make of our own that eliminates these problems and come together as a, as a Zion society?’ And like, how could that be done without technology? How could that be done without sort of the, the godliness of the miraculous?
Carl Youngblood
I think it’s also really important to have an occasional quantifiable perspective as well, where it’s like, I don’t know if you’ve looked at all at a person named Hannah Ritchie, who’s got this site called our, our World in Data, but she often will cite, you know, various statistics about like the degree of poverty in the world and how it’s going down.
Barrett Burgin
It, it, it, it, it, she involved it all with like the, the book of 10 or a hundred great things or something.
Carl Youngblood
I don’t, I’m not sure, but, um, there’s plenty of, yeah, there’s plenty of sources like that, but, um, you know, having, having that larger perspective of saying, you know, there still are bad things in the world, but it’s also important that we not focus entirely on just the things that call our attention. You know, we seem sometimes to be somewhat, um, primed to remember bad experiences, painful experiences, maybe part as part of our evolutionary history, true. We survived better if we remembered the pains that, but for that same reason, um, you know, having a, an occasional like perspective check where we, we realized, oh, you know what? Um, actually overall, a lot of these technologies were used for improving our situation rather than merely for making things worse.
Barrett Burgin
We don’t feel right, cause we, where the tide rises and we just get used to it.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah.
Barrett Burgin
And, and it’s like, well, in comparison to how most of humans have lived for all of time, we’re doing pretty well.
Carl Youngblood
Yeah.
Barrett Burgin
We’re, we’re, we’re doing all right.
Carl Youngblood
Be sure to check out our Transfigurist artwork series with posters, framed prints, puzzles, and apparel portraying inspiring glimpses of what future pioneers might achieve in a vibrant retrofuturist style. Buy them on our website at transfigurism.org/store. Every purchase helps us to make more of this kind of quality content. The other most important thing you can do to show your support is to like and subscribe and leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. Now, back to the show.
Carl Youngblood
We’ve just gone on so many different far ranging topics here.
Barrett Burgin
This is really fun.
Carl Youngblood
Are there any final thoughts you have for our audience?
Barrett Burgin
Sure. Okay. You know, we didn’t dive into these. We, we could, we could another time, you know, I, I spend a lot of time talking about darkness and the utility kind of within our theology personally, even, but kind of to your point, I just want to touch on imagination and how, you know, Latter-day Saint culture, theology, doctrine, tradition lends itself so, so seamlessly to new ways of thinking about things when it comes to the divine. Or conversely, we can look at like further light and knowledge discovery and apply it to like how we have been understanding these, these, uh, these concepts.
Barrett Burgin
Again, I want to stress the point. I think it’s very important to be specific. I think it’s very important to be mythological, to look at things very specifically and go, what do we make of this in this context? And to do so because that, that actually breeds the more philosophical intuition.
Barrett Burgin
So I, I made a little list here of some things and we don’t have to dive into any one of these. Oh, I mean, happy to go deeper if you’d like to. This is so exciting, right? That Latter-day Saint theology and cosmology teaches that we’re not just a limited small species on this planet, that God, for whatever reason in his mercy has forgiven for violating his, his law and was willing to save us because he loves us. That the cosmos is teeming with life and intelligence and that, you know, we might be eons away, but that in the Pearl of Great Price, God says that worlds without number has he created and, and filled with his children that somewhere right now that other intelligent beings are having some kind of conversation and feeling things and trying to better their lives and trying to spread light and goodness. And what a cool idea, what a great concept, you know?
Barrett Burgin
And I kind of like a, what’s it called the, the evolutionary theory that, um, you know, because birds have, uh, because flight has, um, evolved differently, uh, convergent, convergent evolution, uh, lends itself to the idea that in a carbon-based universe, and if life kind of meets certain requirements and that if some ideal kind of form is going to take shape, that convergent evolution lends itself to the idea that these are people in some form or another, that these are, these are human-like at least in, in the image of God. And that’s a very literal way of looking at it, but it’s interesting. It’s, it’s cool that there’s room to imagine it that way.
Carl Youngblood
And that image could be interpreted more broadly or more narrowly, right? Absolutely. Um, it’s, I mean, it’s both thought-provoking and provocative to think of it either way, but, um, I, I find these concepts, this general concept that we sometimes call theosis as one of the greatest hits of Mormonism. For sure. Absolutely. Yeah. Like, let’s riff on that for a minute. Like, tell me more. What, what is so exciting for you about this and what, um, what are some of the ramifications for your work and for humanity generally?
Barrett Burgin
Well, I think that there’s a, there’s a naturalism to Latter-day Saint theology that I really like that, you know, Elder Neal A. Maxwell called us, God’s an embryo. Like that kind of visualization that life is even in a, in a larger sense, embryonic and that, you know, there are patterns of patterns of patterns all the way up and down that sort of reflect each other. I’m sure you’ve seen the, the interesting ways that shapes develop in nature at scale, you know, large and small. And that Christ said, you know, whatever he does, he’s seen the father do. And that early Latter-day Saint prophets and apostles taught that we’re literal children of heavenly parents and in that we’re of the same species of the same substance. And that there is, you know, whatever the spirit is, whatever the, the, the transference of kind of the spirit that lends itself to evolutionary biology, that there’s an evolution of Godhood, that there’s an evolution of progress that we’re eternally progressing.
Barrett Burgin
And, you know, I have no idea why there was such a reticence against evolution within our culture, other than as a response. And also a need for the scriptures to be literal in the way that they’re presenting themselves, even though that’s not the function of how we even deal with them in the temple. And so what that lends itself to is that if it can be done, it will be done. And, and going back to my type three civilization, you know, I like kind of thought experiment, like we know space time can be bent. You know, we know that there are things that we don’t know that can be done. And at a certain point, like to what point would we need to get to before it’s like, well, this kind of qualifies as God-like, you know, the power that can be harnessed through energy and through technology.
Carl Youngblood
And I mean, it’s even the interesting that what it means to be God-like is somewhat relative depending on what our current state is, right?
Barrett Burgin
Oh, that’s, that’s actually a really good point because, because we would, we would emphasize the characteristics and the traits of a God-like character. I feel like oftentimes I hear about God’s power and it’s like, okay, but you know, like power is relative and it, that it’s achievable.
Carl Youngblood
Well, for example, if our distant ancestors were to see us now, they might be quite amazed at some of the things that we’re able to easily, you know, we draw water from a sink rather than having to go down to the river or whatever it is, you know, and yes, all sorts of little things that maybe you and I take for granted, uh, can be thought of as true miracles from their perspective.
Barrett Burgin
So it’s, it’s, uh, Terryl Givens talks about the collapse of sacred distance. I think there’s value in keeping some sacred distance in that it becomes very easy to project one’s own, you know, ethical framework onto God, the closer that he is. And I just don’t think that’s productive because there are, as I’ve demonstrated, as we’ve been talking, there are paradoxical things that happen where it’s like, actually, the thing I don’t like is the very thing that’s good and vice versa.
Barrett Burgin
But what’s so great about the collapse of sacred distance is it is this personal relationship. And so it lends itself to an infinity of infinities all of a sudden. And that, and that becomes the larger godliness in my view. It’s, you know, theosis and especially an infinite theosis that just is kind of the texture of life. It is chaos and order in conversation with itself.
Barrett Burgin
And sometimes, you know, we get accused. I’ve seen it online. I was like, ‘That sounds very atheist. Like, are you guys atheists?’ It’s like, well, it’s not atheist. It’s theist by nature. But it is, it is kind of accommodating nature and patterns. And this is how it always has been. And some of the most beautiful parts of our tradition really dive into this.
Carl Youngblood
I’m thinking in particular of W.W. Phelps, ‘If you could hie to Kolob, do you think that you could ever through all eternity find out the generation where gods began to be?’ Exactly. Right. That’s where I just, I know there’s discussion. We seem to be wanting to downplay some of these concepts, but they’re so beautiful from
Barrett Burgin
our tradition.
Carl Youngblood
They’re beautiful.
Barrett Burgin
And in my opinion, they demand, how do I put this? Let me, let me think of another way to put this. I have seen arguments from within Latter-day Saint culture and kind of armchair apologetics trying to downplay the idea of infinite regress. The idea that God had a God, had a God, had a God, had an infinitum. It’s a current topic, right? It’s the current topic.
Carl Youngblood
It’s even on YouTube, right? It’s on YouTube.
Barrett Burgin
Yeah. And I couldn’t disagree more. You know, I don’t, I don’t mean to be combative, but I actually think it’s ridiculous. And the reason I think it’s ridiculous, I, I’ll tell a little story briefly.
Barrett Burgin
I had a friend in high school, good guy, you know, great guy, smart guy. I felt bad for him because he was constrained to kind of work within the parameters of what the Bible says. We just have to kind of deal with it. And he got into an argument with a friend of mine who is secular about whether there was life in the universe. And he’s like, ‘There isn’t, it’s only on earth, you know,’ and like that it’s a, ‘How do you know?’ ‘Yeah, that’s right.’ And he’s like, ‘The Bible doesn’t say anything about it, you know?’ And, and he, he, this is a common, this is a common view. I’ve heard this my whole life.
Carl Youngblood
Very geocentric, right?
Barrett Burgin
Not everybody, but to the extent that the view is kind of sola scriptura and fundamentalist.
Carl Youngblood
It’s funny that I thought you were going to say the guy was atheist. They just didn’t think there was life elsewhere in the, no, no, no, sorry.
Barrett Burgin
I should be more clear. My friend who was a Christian was arguing with my friend who was an atheist and my friend who was an atheist said there’s for sure life.
Carl Youngblood
So this is fascinating though, that you can hear these kinds of arguments from both of those sides.
Barrett Burgin
Well, and he, and he said, ‘Nope, the Bible doesn’t talk about it. Like, you know, man, God, God made man, God made the whole universe.’ Okay. We’re going to talk about that in a minute. ‘The whole universe. And man is like what he cares about.’ And my atheist friend, you know, or secular, I don’t know if he’s religious, but, uh, or a atheist, but he, he doesn’t belong to a religion. He, he was like, ‘It’s a statistical inevitability that there’s life elsewhere in the universe.’ Like you, and I’m sure my other friend didn’t know about this, like the Fermi paradox can kind of make the case that maybe there’s not intelligent life. I don’t know.
Barrett Burgin
But I, I feel like, you know, as one of the hymns say, I think it’s Eliza Snow’s, uh, Oh My Father, which is another complimentary hymn to this and, and, and accounts for, accounts for biology and sexuality and that God is embodied in male and female. Um, the thought makes reason stare to me. The thought makes reason stare that there is not an infinite regress because as I described when it came to the galaxies, right, just these two galaxies that are close together, humans cannot like wrap their minds around how big the, the observable universe is. You see videos of it, like zooming out and that kind of does it.
Barrett Burgin
But I think when we talk about these, these, some of these theological aspects and what God’s up to with the nations and with, with humanity and stuff, if you’re really familiar with, you know, astronomy and the universe and the scope of things, it becomes more and more ridiculous and laughable the, the more you zoom out and it does give you awe and wonder. But in, in my view, like Latter-day Saint theology in suddenly becoming infinities of infinities is the only sustainable, like serious cosmological theology that, that I, I, maybe it’s a personal doubt thing for me, but I’m just like, I’m sorry. There’s no, no, like on that planet born on that planet. And it happens to be us and our very specific, but the hubris of it.
Carl Youngblood
And whether you’re talking about, um, individual planetary systems, individual galaxies, I’m talking about individual universes. It’s like at all scales.
Barrett Burgin
Yes. It all scales. Yeah. Scale that, that, thank you for putting it that way. Scale lends itself to eternal, eternal recurrence. Recurrence. Yeah.
Barrett Burgin
You know, uh, the Doctrine and Covenants 132 talks about eternal lives. Um, you know, God, eternal lives is another way of talking about recurrence, right? Yeah. Recurrence. And that, you know, many worlds have passed away, many more in the endowment. There’s this argument about what’s been done on other worlds already. And well, here is where, this is where father learned his knowledge. And like, so there it’s baked into the theology. I don’t understand.
Carl Youngblood
It almost seems to come more naturally to a more primitive culture than to like our modern scientific era for some reason.
Barrett Burgin
And so then it becomes like, well, why do we need, why do we, I’m going to get into the polemic arguments just for a moment, just because I think they’re important on their own. You know, you want to appeal to the value system of someone else. You can’t, you can’t hammer science, you know, you can’t hammer theology with science. And it’s like, okay, let’s qualify it for a minute. Why are Latter-day Saints obsessed with this right now?
Barrett Burgin
It’s to fit in. It’s 100% to appeal to our Protestant Catholic friends and just be like, ‘No, we, we believe Christ is the eternal God. It says there right there in the, in the Book of Mormon. So, you know, God and Christ have been with each other from the beginning and like, we’re, we’re uncreated.’ And it’s like, okay, man, that’s really interesting, like the eternal nature of our, of our, you know, material.
Carl Youngblood
Not to open up another can of worms, but it’s quite interesting that even at the time, at a time when mainstream Christianity is diminishing in its influence over our general secular culture and is even becoming in some ways unpopular. Yeah. We’re still courting that opinion when in fact, maybe appealing to broader secular view and figuring out how to talk to that, that register has to be more effective.
Barrett Burgin
And an esoteric.
Carl Youngblood
And we talk about this all the time. And it’s like, I find often more openness to, uh, many of the ideas that we, that come from our tradition from secular atheists than they do. No, I am.
Barrett Burgin
I’m trying so hard to, to, to be professional and polite about this, but like, it drives me crazy. If you look at at least certain, certain strains, I’m not going to lump everyone together, but certain strains of like the, the, the, the, the, the functions of power within the evangelical Christian world right now, are they not abominable?
Barrett Burgin
Is there not some form of abomination that like, in, in creating the sort of this juxtaposition? And I don’t mean people, I don’t mean whole religious groups, but this, this tension between the Latter-day Saints and particularly like what qualifies as Christian is just so ironic to me. It’s like chasing this thing that it’s like, is this, is this really what we want to be? Is this what we want to be a part of? Like we have so much more to give. We have, ‘Take your truth and let us add to it.’ And not just with secular atheists and that, that my best friend is an atheist.
Carl Youngblood
He loves more agnostic, whatever you’re talking about, more than just a general secular culture.
Barrett Burgin
Yes, my buddy, my buddy, one of my best friends, I was just at his wedding earlier this year, a friend from high school. He, he found so much comfort in Latter-day Saint ideology and theology. He’s like, ‘Almost thou convinces me,’ kind of thing. He’s like, ‘I,’ he’s like, ‘if I was anything, it would be Mormon.’ He’s like, ‘I can’t make myself believe in God,’ but I find this all over the Bay Area tech, tech, tech circles. It’s, it happens a lot.
Carl Youngblood
So I’ve, I’ve even had people in rationalist circles say things like, ‘If I could only get behind all the claims, I would totally be Latter-day Saint,’ which, which again is why I make my appeal
Barrett Burgin
to, it’s like, what are the claims functional for? What are they actually doing? You need the claims. They have to be, they have to be unbelievable to be useful, and that’s demonstrable. But when it comes to this argument, I want to get back to this, that like, you know, infinite regress can’t possibly exist because the Book of Mormon says Christ is the eternal God and has always been with the Father. And, and it’s like, how could he be eternal? How could, how, how, how could that be eternal? If he, if he’s the eternal God and that you can’t have this sort of replication and, you know, King Follett sermon doesn’t count.
Carl Youngblood
Like it’s somewhat embarrassing from a philosophical perspective. A hundred percent.
Barrett Burgin
That’s where it comes from. And it, it, it’s not even consistent with Latter-day Saint thought. It’s like, okay, well, what about the Doctrine and Covenant section that qualifies the words ‘endless’ and ‘eternal’? God literally says, ‘Endless is my punishment. Eternal is my punishment.’ And he’s like, ‘I don’t want you to think I mean without end.’ Like it, it doesn’t, it doesn’t go on forever, but something can be eternal this way, or it can be eternal that way.
Barrett Burgin
If the galaxy is regenerating, you know, within the time that it takes light to get from here to here, a new star, is that not a form of eternal? Yeah. And, and about different scales, right? Scales and things collapsing and growing. It’s like, well, something can be infinite, eternal, or endless without needing to be a superlative, without this need to be like, well, it, it diminishes the majesty, or a singularity.
Barrett Burgin
Yes. Yeah. That it’s, it’s collapsing it into a singularity. And it’s like, that feels like the archaic impulse to be like, ‘My God’s bigger than yours.’ You know, he’s the, he’s the OG. And, and even the way that God qualifies, you know, himself or themselves in scripture, it’s like, you have this evolution in Mormonism already where it’s like, it’s like this monotheistic, like, ‘There’s no God.’ You have the Book of Abraham where it’s always referred to as the gods, Elohim.
Carl Youngblood
Uh-huh. That’s right.
Barrett Burgin
And, and, and you can look back and it evolves, right? And so there’s this focus on the monotheism to overcome the idols. But then in the new Testament, he’s like, well, Paul’s like, well, there’s Lord’s many and God’s many, but to you, to us, there’s one Lord, Jesus Christ, one God, the father. And then finally in, in the doctrine and covenants, God qualifies himself and he tells Joseph Smith and D&C 121, whether there be one God or many gods, it shall be revealed to you. But for, for now, and you know, I have a friend that like nitpicks this and it’s like, well, it’s God’s with a capital or capital G one God versus God’s with a lowercase G. And I’m like, guys, what are we doing?
Barrett Burgin
Don’t you see how much, how much more expansive it is to think about our theology in a way that’s so much more complimentary with the shape of the universe, which recurs the, the expansion and the, the, the new universes and new galaxies? Like this is what science all points to. And when the Lord talks about the earth, he says, ‘There is room enough and to spare.’ And, and I, I think that applies to everything. I think that scales up. There is room enough and to spare. It’s like, ‘Don’t worry, everyone.’
Barrett Burgin
And I don’t think it, I don’t think it limits the majesty of God to think about, and I’m not going to, I’m not going to put, I’m not going to put any kind of parameters. I have no idea, but like just speculatively thinking, if God, as we conceive of God, was limited to the Milky Way galaxy, you know, that is so incomprehensibly gigantic. And a Types Three civilization is so beyond the scope of what we can even wrap our heads around to be able to harness the energy of a galaxy. How would one do this? How could this even be conceivable? That 100,000% like fits the descriptions, any descriptions we can think of as God, the same way that we, if we were to go back in time or bring an ancient person here, they would be like, ‘I can’t, I can’t describe this. I don’t know. I don’t know what to make of this.’
Barrett Burgin
And so this need for there not to be any kind of infinite regress, I think comes from, you know, this want for it to be simple and for a God to be so big that we can’t imagine his power. But it’s like, that’s already true. And we already have so much of this in Latter-day Saint theology and history that I think it opens conversations to look at it that way rather than closes them, rather than limits them. And ironically, I think it’s limiting godliness to think that if it’s been done this way and if it’s being done now, an almost simulation theory applied to theology, like if it’s being done, then was it not already done? You know, I hope that makes sense. I know that’s a rant.
Carl Youngblood
What a powerful adventure of the spirit you’ve taken us on, Barrett Burgin. I’m so grateful for this chance. We got to just riff off all these wonderful, inspiring topics. And I hope we have a continued conversation on this. I think that there’s so much more we could dig into, but I want to thank you for your contributions to our culture with the wonderful, creative things that you’re doing and for coming on the show on the Pioneers podcast, which is just getting started here. Hopefully we’ll have more amazing guests like you. And please spread the word about our new Transfigurist artwork series.
Carl Youngblood
I will. I’m going to get some of them. Maybe give some Christmas presents or something to folks. Yeah, absolutely. Thanks again. And we’ll hope to have you on again soon. Bye.